Satellite Internet Vs. 3G

by Elizabeth Streeter, Demand Media

For people who move around a lot or live in remote areas, cable and DSL Internet services may not be versatile enough, or even available. This is where 3G and satellite Internet services shine. Both services allow flexibility. However, the services differ in cost, availability and required equipment.

Equipment

Wireless service providers offer 3G service for smartphones. These companies may also provide 3G broadband cards that allow broadband access for laptops and other portable computers. Satellite Internet, on the other hand, requires a modem and the installation of a satellite dish.

Speed

Users of 3G can expect Internet speeds between 144 kilobits per second (Kbps) and 2 megabits per second (Mbps). The speeds vary widely based on the carrier and coverage. For satellite connections, download speeds extend up to 2 Mbps and upload speeds extend up to 80 Kbps.

Availability and Mobility

Satellite Internet is generally available for customers who live in remote areas where DSL and cable services are often unavailable. For portability, satellite providers can install Internet services on vehicles like RVs and buses. Mobile broadband is more portable than satellite broadband services because of the relative size of broadband cards and cellular phones.

Reliability

Some people find that 3G services aren't available in some areas. In these cases, users may have to rely on slower mobile broadband options like the EDGE network, which is capable of speeds up to 200 Kbps. Satellite connections tend to be unreliable in bad weather such as severe thunderstorms. Satellite Internet connections may also be interrupted if something blocks the satellite dish's view of the sky. Some companies provide backup dial-up services in case of outages.

Price

Prices vary widely based on the provider. Prepaid mobile broadband services for AT&T; and Verizon Wireless, for example, cost around $30 per week for 300 MB and $50 per month for 1 GB for computer access as of June 2011. HughesNet offers basic satellite service with download speeds up to 1 Mbps for around $60 per month, and 2 Mbps for $110 per month.

Considerations

Satellite and 3G Internet services may require signing a contract or renting equipment. Some cell phone service providers offer broadband services for laptop users without a contract, but the equipment must be purchased separately. Satellite services limit how much data users can transfer per day. Some cell phone companies charge additional fees if the monthly data allotment is surpassed.

Find Internet Service Provider deals in your area:

privacy & security protected

References

  • CNET; CNET's Quick Guide; Types of 3G
  • CNET; CNET's Quick Guide; 3G glossary
  • PreventGuru.com: High Speed Internet Connections and High Speed Satellite Internet
  • HughesNet: Plans & Pricing
  • Verizon Wireless: 3G Mobile Broadband Plans
  • AT&T;: Mobile Broadband Center

About the Author

Elizabeth Streeter has been writing professionally since 2000. She specializes in subjects ranging from how to live a happier life to potentially harmful food and drug-related interactions. Streeter has written for "Family Circle," "Woman's Day," "Natural Health" and "Fitness." Streeter holds a Bachelor of Science in nutrition science from Auburn University and is currently working towards a Master of Arts in psychology.

Photo Credits

  • Stockbyte/Stockbyte/Getty Images