Pros & Cons of Cable Modems Vs DSL

by Andrew Latham, Demand Media

DSL connections use existing telephone cables and are therefore available in more isolated and rural areas.

John Foxx/Stockbyte/Getty Images

The choice between a cable modem and a DSL Internet connection is usually a matter of weighing the speed, availability and cost of each connection type. A lot depends on the purpose for which you need to connect to the Internet and where you live. However, if you live in an area where you have access to both DSL and cable modem service providers it pays to know the pros and cons of each service.

Speed

Speed is the big advantage of cable modems. While the fastest DSL providers may reach 1.5 Mbps, or megabits per second, most cable modem service providers can offer 15 Mbps. Some high-end providers like Optimum Online offer high-speed options that reach 50 Mbps. However, if all you do with your Internet connection is send emails or surf the net, you may not even notice the difference between the two options. On the other hand, if you download and upload large files regularly as part of your business, a cable modem may be a necessity.

Cost

The increase in competition among cable modem providers has brought down the cost of broadband cable modem connections, but DSL is still the cheapest option. Add to this that a cable modem connection usually involves connection and installation fees, and you can see DSL is still the best choice for budget-conscious consumers. Also, note that a cable modem provider usually requires a long contract to ensure its initial investment in your cable installation pays off.

Coverage

If you live in an isolated or rural area, it is unlikely you have access to a cable modem Internet connection. DSL, however, is available to most homes with a phone line. An older telephone installation may not allow for DSL and a dial-up connection may be required.

Bonus Packages

Large telecommunication corporations are trying to corner the market by providing full communication packages that provide cable TV, broadband high-speed Internet and VoIP telephone connection at discount prices. If you plan to have cable TV, it might be cheaper to include Internet in your cable TV package than to purchase DSL from another provider.

References

  • MIT: High-Speed Remote Acces to MITnet
  • Insight Research Corporation: DSL vs Cable Modems

Resources

  • Consumer Reports; Internet Service; Feb. 2007

About the Author

Andrew Latham has worked as a professional copywriter since 2005 and is the owner of LanguageVox, a Spanish and English language services provider. His work has been published in "Property News" and on the San Francisco Chronicle's website, SFGate. Latham holds a Bachelor of Science in English and a diploma in linguistics from Open University.

Photo Credits

  • John Foxx/Stockbyte/Getty Images